The Best YNAB Alternatives for Every Kind of Budgeter
Looking beyond YNAB? Compare envelope apps, all-in-one trackers and free options by price, bank sync, sharing and history import, and find the one that fits.
YNAB (You Need A Budget) has helped a lot of people take control of their money, and many who leave it keep its method for life. People look for alternatives for a handful of reasons: the price, wanting a budget that’s less hands-on, wanting investments in the same app, or wanting more Quicken-style bookkeeping alongside the budget.
The first question is whether you want to keep envelope budgeting or move away from it. That splits the field in two. This guide covers both, with a fair note on where YNAB itself is still the strongest choice. Prices and features change, so check each company’s own site; the details here are what each published when this post was written.
What YNAB does well, so you know what you’re replacing
Before switching, be clear about what you’d be giving up. YNAB offers:
- A focused envelope (zero-based) method, with a large library of guides and a community built around it.
- Direct import from select banks in the US, Canada, the UK and the EU, with file import elsewhere.
- Apps on the web, iPhone and Android.
- Sharing with up to six people on one subscription.
- Account registers with splits and reconciliation, and loan accounts with a payoff planner.
It costs $109 a year or $14.99 a month, after a 34-day free trial, and YNAB offers college students a free year. If price is your only complaint, run the numbers: $109 a year is about $9 a month, and for some people one avoided overdraft or late fee covers that.
The alternatives at a glance
| Budget style | Price | Bank sync | Platforms | Brings YNAB history | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kemback | Envelope or category, switchable | Free plan; Plus coming soon | Coming with Plus; file import today | Web; iPhone app in beta | Coming soon |
| Actual Budget | Envelope | Free, open source | Via GoCardless (EU/UK) or SimpleFIN (US/Canada) | Local app with optional self-hosted sync | Yes, built-in importers |
| Monarch Money | Flexible, by category or group | $99.99 a year or $14.99 a month | Yes | Web, iPhone, Android | Check Monarch’s help center |
| Copilot Money | Monthly budgets with optional rollover | $95 a year | Yes | iPhone, iPad, Mac, web | Check Copilot’s help center |
| Quicken Simplifi | Spending plan | $6.99 a month billed annually, lower first-year offer | Yes | Web, iPhone, Android | Check Quicken’s site |
| A spreadsheet | Whatever you build | Free | No | Anywhere | Paste in an export |
If you want to keep envelope budgeting
Kemback
Kemback has a true envelope mode: you budget the money you have, assign it until ready to assign reaches zero, and move money between envelopes when plans change. It also has a category mode, a plan per category the way Mint and Quicken did it, and you can switch between modes without losing anything. That’s useful if one person in a couple loves envelopes and the other doesn’t.
Around the budget, Kemback offers a register with splits, transfers and statement reconciliation, bills with a calendar, safe to spend, savings goals, reports and alerts. Each household member signs in separately, and accounts can be shared or private.
The honest gaps: no automatic bank sync yet (you import OFX, QFX, QIF or CSV files from your bank, and sync is coming with Plus), the iPhone app is in beta, Android and Windows apps are in development, and there’s no investment tracking. A Switch from YNAB import is being built now and is coming soon. The Free plan is complete; Plus will be $79 a year or $7.99 a month, and the first 500 people who join the waitlist on the pricing page get a founding price of $59 a year for as long as they stay subscribed. There’s a full Kemback vs YNAB comparison.
Actual Budget
Actual Budget is free, open-source envelope budgeting. It’s a local app, with your data synced in the background through a sync service you host yourself or through a hosting provider. It has built-in importers for both YNAB4 and current YNAB that keep your history, and bank sync through GoCardless (EU and UK) or SimpleFIN (US and Canada). It suits people comfortable with a little technical setup who want to own their data completely.
If you want something less hands-on
Monarch Money
Monarch is an all-in-one app: bank sync through several data providers, investments, real estate and loans in one net worth view, and budgets you can set by category or group. You can invite a partner. Core is $99.99 a year or $14.99 a month, and a Plus tier at $199 a year adds forecasting, business tracking and deeper investment analysis. It runs on the web, iPhone and Android. If the YNAB method felt like too much work, Monarch’s more flexible approach may suit you.
Copilot Money
Copilot is an Apple-first app for iPhone, iPad and Mac, with a web app. It categorizes transactions with AI, offers monthly budgets with an option to roll leftovers over, and tracks stocks, crypto and real estate. It’s $95 a year after a one-month trial, and it doesn’t list an Android app.
Quicken Simplifi
Simplifi focuses on a spending plan and cash flow projections, with sync to more than 14,000 institutions, investment monitoring and sharing with one other person. It runs on the web, iPhone and Android. Quicken lists it at $6.99 a month billed annually, with a lower first-year offer.
A spreadsheet
If what you value is the method rather than the software, a spreadsheet can run an envelope budget for free. You’ll enter or paste transactions yourself and build your own reports. Some people use one for a few months while they decide.
How to switch without losing your footing
- Pick a start date at the beginning of a month. Envelope budgets are easiest to restart from a clean month.
- Export your YNAB data and keep it, even if your new app can’t import it.
- Write down every account balance on your start date, and start the new app from those balances.
- Recreate your categories, including targets for irregular expenses like car repairs and gifts.
- Run both for a month if your YNAB subscription allows, then compare.
Switching budgeting apps mid-year has a fuller checklist.
Which should you choose?
- Stay with YNAB if bank sync matters, you rely on its envelope workflow and community, and $109 a year is worth it. Plenty of people decide that it is.
- Choose Kemback if you want envelope budgeting (or both envelopes and categories) without a subscription, plus a reconcilable register and a household with private accounts, and you can import bank files weekly until Plus arrives.
- Choose Actual Budget if you want free, open-source envelope budgeting with your YNAB history brought across, and you’re comfortable with some setup.
- Choose Monarch, Copilot or Simplifi if you want automatic sync, investments and a less hands-on budget, and you’re happy to pay for it. Copilot suits Apple households; Monarch and Simplifi cover Android too.
Whatever you pick, keep the habit that made YNAB work for you: look at your budget every week, and give your money a plan before you spend it.
This article is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. For decisions about your situation, talk to a qualified professional.
Keep reading
Kemback vs Monarch Money: Which Fits Your Household?
Kemback vs Monarch Money: price, bank sync, investments, budgeting styles, sharing and platforms compared honestly, so you can pick the right one for you.
Kemback vs Quicken: How It Compares to Simplifi and Quicken Classic
Kemback vs Quicken Simplifi and Quicken Classic: price, bank sync, investments, platforms, sharing and your history, compared fairly so you can choose well.
The Best Quicken Alternatives, and How to Pick the Right One
Thinking of leaving Quicken? Compare the main alternatives by what they replace: the register, investments, bank sync, sharing and price. Then choose well.