Paying Off Student Loans: Strategies to Consider
Strategies for paying off student loans: knowing your loans, repayment plans, extra payments, refinancing trade-offs and forgiveness, with worked examples.
Student loans are often the largest debt people carry before a mortgage, and they come with more choices than most other debts: different repayment plans, possible forgiveness programs, refinancing, and rules that change from time to time. The right strategy depends on what kind of loans you have, what you earn, and what you do for a living. This guide covers the main options for US borrowers so you can ask good questions. Federal programs in particular change, so confirm the current details at StudentAid.gov or with your loan servicer before acting.
Step 1: Know exactly what you owe
Before choosing a strategy, make a list of every loan:
- Type: federal (from the government) or private (from a bank, credit union or online lender). This is the most important distinction.
- Balance and interest rate for each loan. You may have several loans at different rates, even with one servicer.
- Servicer: the company you pay. Federal loans can move between servicers, so check.
- Current repayment plan and monthly payment.
For federal loans, your account at StudentAid.gov lists every federal loan you have. Private loans appear on your credit report and on your lender’s statements.
Step 2: Understand the repayment plans available to you
Federal loans
Federal loans offer several kinds of repayment plan:
- Standard plans with a fixed payment over a set term, often 10 years. These usually cost the least in total interest.
- Graduated or extended plans that start lower or stretch the term, which lowers the monthly payment but raises total interest.
- Income-driven plans that set your payment as a share of your income and family size, with any remaining balance potentially forgiven after a long period of payments.
The names and terms of these plans, especially the income-driven ones, have changed several times and may change again. Check StudentAid.gov for what is currently offered and what you qualify for. The servicer can also run the numbers for you.
Private loans
Private loans have whatever terms your contract says. They usually lack income-driven plans and forgiveness, though some lenders offer temporary hardship options. If you are struggling, call the lender early.
Step 3: Decide whether you are aiming for forgiveness or payoff
This choice shapes everything else.
Aiming for forgiveness can make sense if you work in public service or for a qualifying nonprofit and may be eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), which forgives the remaining federal balance after a set number of qualifying payments while working full time for a qualifying employer. In that case, paying extra usually doesn’t help you; you would generally want the lowest qualifying payment and careful records. Confirm your employer and your loans qualify, and certify your employment regularly.
Aiming to pay off makes sense for most people with private loans, people with moderate balances relative to their income, and anyone who doesn’t expect to qualify for forgiveness. In that case, the goal is to pay as little interest as possible.
If you are unsure which applies to you, this is worth an hour with your servicer or a financial professional.
Step 4: If you are paying off, pay extra wisely
A worked example
Jordan owes $30,000 at 5.5% on a 10-year standard plan.
- Monthly payment: about $326
- Total interest over 10 years: about $9,070
If Jordan adds $100 a month (about $426 total):
- Paid off in about 7 years 2 months
- Total interest: about $6,320
- Saving: about $2,750
If Jordan adds $200 a month (about $526 total):
- Paid off in about 5 years 7 months
- Total interest: about $4,860
- Saving: about $4,210
(Simplified: one loan, fixed rate, monthly interest. Real loans may calculate interest daily.)
Make sure extra payments go where you want
Servicers may apply an extra payment toward future payments (“paying ahead”) rather than reducing principal. Tell your servicer, in writing or through their online options, to apply extra amounts to principal on your highest-rate loan. Then check your statements to confirm it happened.
Federal student loans have no prepayment penalty, and US law generally prohibits prepayment penalties on private education loans too, but it is worth confirming in your loan terms.
Avalanche or snowball
With several loans, the same two methods used for other debt apply. Paying extra on the highest-rate loan first (avalanche) saves the most interest. Paying off the smallest balance first (snowball) clears loans faster for motivation. Private loans often carry higher rates than federal ones, so they frequently come first under the avalanche method.
Small things that add up
- Autopay discounts. Many servicers and lenders reduce your rate slightly, often 0.25 percentage points, for automatic payments. Check whether yours does.
- Paying interest during deferment or grace periods. On many loans, interest that builds up can be added to the principal later. Paying it as it accrues can prevent that.
- The student loan interest deduction. Depending on your income and current tax rules, some of the interest you pay may be deductible. Limits change, so check the current rules or ask a tax professional.
- Employer help. Some employers offer student loan repayment assistance as a benefit. It is worth asking HR.
Refinancing: the trade-off
Refinancing means taking a new private loan to pay off existing loans, ideally at a lower rate.
Possible benefits:
- A lower interest rate if your credit and income are strong.
- One payment instead of several.
- A choice of shorter or longer terms.
What you give up if you refinance federal loans:
- Access to income-driven repayment plans.
- Eligibility for federal forgiveness programs, including PSLF.
- Federal deferment and forbearance options if you lose your job or face hardship.
Once federal loans become private, there is no way to turn them back. Refinancing private loans carries far less risk because you aren’t giving up federal protections. Compare offers carefully, including whether the rate is fixed or variable.
Consolidation is different. A federal Direct Consolidation Loan combines federal loans into one federal loan. It can simplify payments and is sometimes needed for program eligibility, but it doesn’t lower your rate (the new rate is a weighted average of the old ones, rounded up slightly) and it can affect progress toward forgiveness in some cases. Ask your servicer before consolidating.
If you are struggling to pay
Don’t stop paying without talking to someone first. For federal loans, missing payments can lead to default, which can bring collection fees, damaged credit, and the government withholding tax refunds or part of your wages. Instead:
- Contact your servicer about switching to an income-driven plan.
- Ask about deferment or forbearance if the problem is temporary. Interest may still build up.
- For private loans, call your lender and ask about hardship options.
A nonprofit credit counselor, such as an agency affiliated with the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, can help you look at student loans alongside your other debts. Be cautious about companies that charge fees to “enroll” you in federal programs; applying for federal repayment plans and forgiveness is free through StudentAid.gov and your servicer.
Keeping track
Student loans run for years, so it helps to see the balance falling. If you use Kemback, each loan can be an account in your register, the monthly payment can be a recurring bill on the calendar, and net worth over time shows the debt shrinking. Keep copies of payment confirmations and any forgiveness paperwork in your own records too.
The takeaway
Find out exactly what you owe and what kind of loans you have. Decide whether you are aiming for forgiveness or payoff. If paying off, put extra toward the highest-rate loan and make sure it reaches principal. Think hard before refinancing federal loans. And if payments become unmanageable, contact your servicer early; there are usually more options before default than after it.
This article is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. For decisions about your situation, talk to a qualified professional.
Keep reading
Debt Snowball vs Debt Avalanche: Which Pays Off Faster?
Snowball or avalanche? We run both methods on the same four debts, month by month, to show what each costs in interest and when to pick one over the other.
Should You Pay Off Debt or Save First?
Pay off debt or build savings? A practical order of priorities, from a starter emergency fund to an employer match, with examples of how to split each dollar.
How to Budget While Paying Off Debt
A practical way to budget while paying off debt: cover essentials, plan for irregular costs, keep fun money and give debt payments a fixed place in the plan.